The Quarters at the Commissary, 34 Van Horne Street, Tybee Island

34 Van Horne Street, Tybee Island - historic white commissary building from the drive, with a green door and a long porch wing

Welcome to 34 Van Horne Street on Tybee Island — The Quarters at the Commissary. Set on approximately 0.7 acres, one of Tybee Island’s larger residential lots, this historically significant property, circa 1907, originally served as Fort Screven’s Commissary and Quartermaster’s Office. Meticulously restored in 2017–2018, it was transformed into three distinctive luxury residences while preserving its military heritage. Offered at $2,500,000.

The restoration earned a 2019 Historic Preservation Award from Historic Savannah Foundation and the 2020 Excellence in Historic Preservation Award from the Tybee Island Historical Society. Distinctive features include a slate roof and a preserved elevator believed to be the oldest in Chatham County. Rendered inoperable for safety, the historic elevator remains a striking reminder of the building’s original purpose.

  • The Residences: Together, the three quarters offer 11 bedrooms and 9 full bathrooms, accommodating up to 30 guests. Hive MLS also lists 2 half baths. A detached one-bedroom caretaker’s cottage adds flexibility.
  • The Living Area: The listing describes more than 8,000 square feet of living area. A full, 4,160-square-foot basement, a rare coastal feature, provides substantial additional space and is not included in that figure. Hive MLS lists the property size as 13,020 square feet.
  • Modern Conveniences: An exterior wheelchair lift serves Unit 1. Two electric vehicle chargers and two golf cart chargers add modern convenience.
  • The Grounds: Approximately 0.7 acres in Fort Screven Ward. The expansive grounds and separate residences offer possibilities for a multigenerational family compound, continued short-term rental use, or a residential bed-and-breakfast, subject to applicable approvals.

The Quarters are being sold furnished and turn-key. Currently operating as a short-term rental, the property offers an opportunity for a new owner to obtain an STR license under the one-time sale provision of Tybee’s new ordinance, effective January 2027, subject to qualifying closing dates and City application requirements.

Contact me for more information or to schedule a private viewing. Sean Williams | Keller Williams Coastal Area Partners, (912) 508-5477.

Details are from Hive MLS and are subject to change. Please confirm information with the listing office.

Listing provided by Sara Bacon, Keller Williams Coastal Area Partners

Explore the blog ↗